{ "at": "2026-08-08T05:03:04.503Z", "account": { "id": "account-claude-code", "label": "Claude Code (subscription)", "type": "cli", "model": "claude-sonnet-5" }, "runsPerTask": 1, "suite": "hard", "taskFilter": null, "durationMs": 7365670, "summary": { "tasks": 5, "taskRunsPassed": 5, "taskRunsTotal": 5, "cleanCompletions": 1, "outcomes": { "complete": 1, "complete_unverified": 0, "needs_user": 0, "timeout": 4, "other": 0, "falseCompletions": 0 }, "checksPassed": 41, "checksTotal": 41, "totalCostUsd": 0, "totalProviderCalls": 273, "totalTokens": 843771, "providerUsageByAgent": { "mira": { "calls": 73, "inTokens": 295457, "outTokens": 30360, "costUsd": 0 }, "forge": { "calls": 28, "inTokens": 161910, "outTokens": 31163, "costUsd": 0 }, "verity": { "calls": 167, "inTokens": 284169, "outTokens": 23166, "costUsd": 0 }, "advisor": { "calls": 4, "inTokens": 5042, "outTokens": 8148, "costUsd": 0 }, "sentinel": { "calls": 1, "inTokens": 4282, "outTokens": 74, "costUsd": 0 } }, "totalSteps": 71 }, "results": [ { "taskId": "hard-build-invoice-studio", "kind": "build", "run": 1, "passed": true, "checks": [ { "name": "index.html exists", "ok": true }, { "name": "loads without page errors, empty invoice shows $0.00", "ok": true }, { "name": "math: two items → correct subtotal", "ok": true }, { "name": "interaction: 10% discount then 20% tax → $248.40 (order matters)", "ok": true }, { "name": "remove recomputes: deleting a row updates subtotal and total", "ok": true }, { "name": "negative path: empty description rejected, nothing added", "ok": true }, { "name": "negative path: hostile qty/price rejected, totals never NaN", "ok": true }, { "name": "discount out of range: error shown, treated as 0", "ok": true }, { "name": "persistence: items and totals survive a reload", "ok": true } ], "endState": "complete", "completedUnproven": false, "failedCriteriaEnd": 0, "behavioralUnproven": 0, "timedOut": false, "interventions": 0, "providerRetries": 0, "steps": 2, "wallMs": 359543, "usage": { "tokens": 52179, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 18, "byAgent": { "mira": { "inTokens": 3313, "outTokens": 1227, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 2 }, "forge": { "inTokens": 15933, "outTokens": 6392, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 4 }, "verity": { "inTokens": 22899, "outTokens": 2415, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 12 } } }, "verdict": "pass", "criteria": { "met": 8, "total": 8 }, "loop": { "planSteps": { "done": 0, "total": 8 }, "selfReviews": 1, "criteriaProven": 8, "digest": false, "shortcuts": 0, "completionShortcuts": 0, "leanStubs": 0, "skillsApplied": 0, "skillsSaved": 1, "fixAttempts": 0, "fixHistory": 0, "broadRegen": 0, "holisticTried": false, "providerRecoveries": 0, "structureChecks": false, "promptStats": { "mira": { "calls": 1, "trims": 0, "maxChars": 3660, "budgetChars": 103219, "lastChars": 3660 } }, "providerQueue": { "waits": 0, "totalMs": 0, "maxMs": 0 }, "ladder": { "started": "fast", "final": "fast", "fastBuildRounds": 1, "completedFast": true, "escalated": false, "escalationReason": "", "fastUsage": { "calls": 13, "tokens": 32684, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 205495 } }, "verification": { "lastRun": { "at": 1786158371063, "workspaceVersion": 3, "verdict": "pass", "hardGreen": true, "deterministicGreen": true, "deterministicChecks": 12, "criteriaAttempted": 8, "runtimeErrors": 0, "receiptKey": "v3:sfull:q3:a0:finding-8u0f1a", "highIssues": 0 }, "efficiency": { "fullPasses": 1, "staticCriteria": 0, "staticDeterministic": 0, "staticBatchCalls": 0, "staticBatchRetries": 0, "workflowCalls": 2, "workflowCriteria": 5 }, "stages": { "workflowPlan": { "calls": 1, "tokens": 1297, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 66682 }, "workflowJudge": { "calls": 1, "tokens": 1416, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 17570 }, "criterionTurn": { "calls": 9, "tokens": 15360, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 63677 }, "finalJudge": { "calls": 1, "tokens": 7241, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 12227 } }, "purposes": { "standard": 1 }, "criteria": [ { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-9f2s4", "text": "Page contains #item-desc, #item-qty, #item-price, #add-item, #item-list, #subtotal, #discount-pct, #tax-pct, #total, #inv-error", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 1, "successfulActions": 1, "modelCalls": 2, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-xc53a", "text": "Adding an item with description 'Widget', qty 2, price 10.50 appends a row to #item-list showing that item's own line total (2 × 10.50 = $21.00) and updates #subtotal to $21.00", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 2, "successfulActions": 2, "modelCalls": 2, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-b83ng", "text": "Each item row has a Remove button with class='remove-item'; clicking it deletes that row and recomputes #subtotal and #total correctly (tested with 2+ items, removing one leaves the correct remaining total)", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 6, "successfulActions": 6, "modelCalls": 3, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-ft807", "text": "Submitting an item with empty description, OR non-positive/non-numeric qty or price (e.g. qty=-1, price='abc', qty=0), adds nothing to #item-list and shows a message in #inv-error", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 6, "successfulActions": 5, "modelCalls": 3, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-3fh3b", "text": "Entering a discount-pct outside 0-100 (e.g. 150 or -10) shows an error in #inv-error and treats discount as 0 in the #total calculation, rather than blocking totals entirely", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 1, "successfulActions": 1, "modelCalls": 2, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-llpse", "text": "With subtotal $100, discount-pct 10, tax-pct 5: #total shows $94.50 (formatted with $ sign and two decimals), and recomputes live on every change to items/discount/tax", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 6, "successfulActions": 6, "modelCalls": 3, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-w5a4p", "text": "With zero items, #subtotal and #total show $0.00 (never NaN, Infinity, or undefined) — verified as the initial state before any items are added", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 1, "successfulActions": 1, "modelCalls": 2, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158038090-q5pfh", "text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly id=\"item-desc\", id=\"item-qty\", id=\"item-price\", id=\"add-item\", id=\"item-list\", class=\"remove-item\", id=\"subtotal\", id=\"discount-pct\", id=\"tax-pct\", id=\"total\", id=\"inv-error\", \"item-desc\"; negative requirements hold literally (NEVER display NaN).", "status": "met", "attempts": 1, "actionAttempts": 2, "successfulActions": 2, "modelCalls": 2, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false } ] }, "improvements": { "brainstormRounds": 0, "shipped": [], "backlogRemaining": 0 } } }, { "taskId": "hard-modify-crm-features", "kind": "modify", "run": 1, "passed": true, "checks": [ { "name": "regression: add updates list and count", "ok": true }, { "name": "regression: search stays case-insensitive", "ok": true }, { "name": "regression: empty name rejected with an error, nothing added", "ok": true }, { "name": "regression: delete works and detail panel still opens", "ok": true }, { "name": "tags: saved on add and shown as .tag chips in the detail panel", "ok": true }, { "name": "tag filter: options populate and filtering works", "ok": true }, { "name": "export: #export-output holds parseable JSON containing the contacts", "ok": true }, { "name": "import: merges new contacts, skips duplicate emails", "ok": true }, { "name": "undo: restores the most recently deleted contact", "ok": true } ], "endState": "timeout", "completedUnproven": false, "failedCriteriaEnd": 0, "behavioralUnproven": 1, "timedOut": true, "interventions": 0, "providerRetries": 0, "steps": 10, "wallMs": 1590229, "usage": { "tokens": 220559, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 88, "byAgent": { "mira": { "inTokens": 32044, "outTokens": 3523, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 8 }, "forge": { "inTokens": 45844, "outTokens": 8609, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 7 }, "verity": { "inTokens": 117724, "outTokens": 9394, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 72 }, "advisor": { "inTokens": 1277, "outTokens": 2144, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 1 } } }, "verdict": "fail", "criteria": { "met": 6, "total": 7 }, "loop": { "planSteps": { "done": 0, "total": 10 }, "selfReviews": 0, "criteriaProven": 6, "digest": true, "shortcuts": 1, "completionShortcuts": 0, "leanStubs": 16, "skillsApplied": 0, "skillsSaved": 0, "fixAttempts": 3, "fixHistory": 3, "broadRegen": 0, "holisticTried": false, "providerRecoveries": 0, "structureChecks": true, "promptStats": {}, "providerQueue": { "waits": 0, "totalMs": 0, "maxMs": 0 }, "ladder": { "started": "fast", "final": "full", "fastBuildRounds": 2, "completedFast": false, "escalated": true, "escalationReason": "the verification pass finished with 2 high-severity finding(s) unresolved", "fastUsage": { "calls": 25, "tokens": 59726, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 464337 } }, "verification": { "lastRun": { "at": 1786159818482, "workspaceVersion": 14, "verdict": "fail", "hardGreen": false, "deterministicGreen": false, "deterministicChecks": 14, "criteriaAttempted": 6, "runtimeErrors": 1, "receiptKey": "v14:sfull:q3:a0:finding-1koo16j", "highIssues": 2 }, "efficiency": { "fullPasses": 4, "staticCriteria": 0, "staticDeterministic": 0, "staticBatchCalls": 0, "staticBatchRetries": 0, "workflowCalls": 8, "workflowCriteria": 0, "scopedPasses": 1, "deferred": 3 }, "stages": { "workflowPlan": { "calls": 4, "tokens": 5567, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 130657 }, "workflowJudge": { "calls": 4, "tokens": 4779, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 86227 }, "criterionTurn": { "calls": 63, "tokens": 116772, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 633183 } }, "purposes": { "standard": 5 }, "criteria": [ { "id": "criterion-1786158403062-tivky", "text": "Add form includes tags input id=\"contact-tags\" accepting comma-separated tags; saved contact's tags render as elements with class=\"tag\" in the detail panel", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 21, "successfulActions": 16, "modelCalls": 9, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158403062-isomv", "text": "A select id=\"tag-filter\" above the contact list has options \"All tags\" (value \"\") plus every distinct tag currently in use; with two contacts having different tags (one shared, one unique), selecting the unique tag filters the list to only the contact(s) with that tag", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 24, "successfulActions": 24, "modelCalls": 6, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": true, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158403062-i3gkt", "text": "Button id=\"export\" writes the full current contact list as valid JSON into textarea id=\"export-output\" when clicked", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 14, "successfulActions": 10, "modelCalls": 8, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158403062-5vnum", "text": "Textarea id=\"import-input\" plus button id=\"import-btn\" parses a JSON array of contacts and merges them into the store, skipping any contact whose email already exists (case-insensitive), and newly imported contacts appear in the list", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 16, "successfulActions": 16, "modelCalls": 6, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": true, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158403062-y1fw4", "text": "After deleting a contact, a button id=\"undo\" appears and clicking it restores that exact contact (fields intact) back into the list", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 17, "successfulActions": 13, "modelCalls": 9, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158403062-5ea46", "text": "Pre-existing features still work: adding a contact with validation and duplicate-email rejection, live search filtering, the contact count, the detail panel on selecting a contact, deleting a contact, and persistence of contacts/tags across reload", "status": "open", "attempts": 5, "actionAttempts": 29, "successfulActions": 29, "modelCalls": 15, "lastResult": "unknown", "unknownReason": "missing-required-actions", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786158403062-eo96b", "text": "All existing and new functionality has no console/runtime errors and passes Reviewer's manual test pass", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 20, "successfulActions": 15, "modelCalls": 10, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": false, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false } ] }, "improvements": { "brainstormRounds": 1, "shipped": [], "backlogRemaining": 8 } } }, { "taskId": "hard-fix-crm-tangle", "kind": "fix", "run": 1, "passed": true, "checks": [ { "name": "regression: add, count and detail still work", "ok": true }, { "name": "bug 1: search is case-insensitive again", "ok": true }, { "name": "bug 2: deleting under an active search removes the RIGHT contact", "ok": true }, { "name": "bug 3: contacts survive a page reload", "ok": true } ], "endState": "timeout", "completedUnproven": false, "failedCriteriaEnd": 0, "behavioralUnproven": 0, "timedOut": true, "interventions": 0, "providerRetries": 0, "steps": 11, "wallMs": 1583445, "usage": { "tokens": 166853, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 61, "byAgent": { "mira": { "inTokens": 36751, "outTokens": 4817, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 11 }, "verity": { "inTokens": 47833, "outTokens": 3953, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 38 }, "advisor": { "inTokens": 951, "outTokens": 1969, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 1 }, "forge": { "inTokens": 63699, "outTokens": 6880, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 11 } } }, "verdict": "fail", "criteria": { "met": 5, "total": 5 }, "loop": { "planSteps": { "done": 4, "total": 11 }, "selfReviews": 0, "criteriaProven": 5, "digest": true, "shortcuts": 2, "completionShortcuts": 0, "leanStubs": 31, "skillsApplied": 0, "skillsSaved": 0, "fixAttempts": 5, "fixHistory": 5, "broadRegen": 0, "holisticTried": false, "providerRecoveries": 0, "structureChecks": true, "promptStats": {}, "providerQueue": { "waits": 1, "totalMs": 21654, "maxMs": 21654 }, "ladder": { "started": "fast", "final": "full", "fastBuildRounds": 0, "completedFast": false, "escalated": true, "escalationReason": "automated checks are failing", "fastUsage": { "calls": 0, "tokens": 0, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 0 } }, "verification": { "lastRun": { "at": 1786161570395, "workspaceVersion": 8, "verdict": "fail", "hardGreen": false, "deterministicGreen": false, "deterministicChecks": 13, "criteriaAttempted": 5, "runtimeErrors": 1, "receiptKey": "v8:sfull:q3:a0:finding-8gr88x", "highIssues": 2 }, "efficiency": { "fullPasses": 4, "staticCriteria": 0, "staticDeterministic": 0, "staticBatchCalls": 0, "staticBatchRetries": 0, "workflowCalls": 4, "workflowCriteria": 0, "scopedPasses": 1, "deferred": 1 }, "stages": { "workflowPlan": { "calls": 4, "tokens": 3400, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 144656 }, "criterionTurn": { "calls": 33, "tokens": 48386, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 259503 } }, "purposes": { "standard": 5 }, "criteria": [ { "id": "criterion-1786160022465-x7dsa", "text": "Typing a search term in a different case than stored (e.g. lowercase 'john' when contact is stored as 'John Smith') still finds and displays that contact", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 15, "successfulActions": 12, "modelCalls": 7, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": true, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786160022465-4nw1d", "text": "With an active search filtering the contact list to a subset, clicking Delete on a specific displayed contact removes exactly that contact (verified by name) and no other contact", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 24, "successfulActions": 18, "modelCalls": 8, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": true, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786160022465-1351k", "text": "After adding/editing contacts and refreshing the page, all previously present contacts are still shown (persisted via localStorage or equivalent)", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 17, "successfulActions": 17, "modelCalls": 8, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": true, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786160022465-ufmli", "text": "Existing features remain functional after the fix: adding a contact, editing a contact, and clearing/resetting the search all still work", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 16, "successfulActions": 16, "modelCalls": 5, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": true, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false }, { "id": "criterion-1786160022465-dxt69", "text": "No UI structure, element ids, or classes were changed, and no existing feature was removed", "status": "met", "attempts": 4, "actionAttempts": 16, "successfulActions": 16, "modelCalls": 5, "lastResult": "met", "unknownReason": "", "replayAttempted": true, "replayFailed": false, "deterministic": false } ] }, "improvements": { "brainstormRounds": 1, "shipped": [], "backlogRemaining": 7 } } }, { "taskId": "vhard-refactor-recipe-monolith", "kind": "refactor", "run": 1, "passed": true, "checks": [ { "name": "structure: at least 4 JS files and no giant file left", "ok": true }, { "name": "loads without page errors", "ok": true }, { "name": "behavior: add recipe updates list and stats; bad time rejected", "ok": true }, { "name": "behavior: ingredients + scaling math (4 → 10 servings, 2.5×)", "ok": true }, { "name": "behavior: shopping list merges duplicates instead of double-listing", "ok": true }, { "name": "behavior: favorites toggle + stats count", "ok": true }, { "name": "behavior: search + category filter + time sort still compose", "ok": true }, { "name": "behavior: notes save and persist; recipes survive reload", "ok": true }, { "name": "new feature: Duplicate creates a full copy named \"(copy)\"", "ok": true }, { "name": "new feature: #clear-shopping empties the shopping list", "ok": true } ], "endState": "timeout", "completedUnproven": false, "failedCriteriaEnd": 0, "behavioralUnproven": 3, "timedOut": true, "interventions": 0, "providerRetries": 0, "steps": 24, "wallMs": 1890835, "usage": { "tokens": 189845, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 49, "byAgent": { "mira": { "inTokens": 108064, "outTokens": 9466, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 26 }, "forge": { "inTokens": 18279, "outTokens": 4741, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 2 }, "verity": { "inTokens": 42676, "outTokens": 3241, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 20 }, "advisor": { "inTokens": 1297, "outTokens": 2081, "costUsd": 0, "calls": 1 } } }, "verdict": "incomplete", "criteria": { "met": 5, "total": 8 }, "loop": { "planSteps": { "done": 5, "total": 9 }, "selfReviews": 0, "criteriaProven": 5, "digest": true, "shortcuts": 0, "completionShortcuts": 0, "leanStubs": 0, "skillsApplied": 0, "skillsSaved": 0, "fixAttempts": 0, "fixHistory": 0, "broadRegen": 0, "holisticTried": false, "providerRecoveries": 0, "structureChecks": true, "promptStats": {}, "providerQueue": { "waits": 0, "totalMs": 0, "maxMs": 0 }, "ladder": { "started": "fast", "final": "full", "fastBuildRounds": 1, "completedFast": false, "escalated": true, "escalationReason": "one full verification pass could not prove every criterion", "fastUsage": { "calls": 21, "tokens": 55080, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 445300 } }, "verification": { "lastRun": { "at": 1786162168227, "workspaceVersion": 7, "verdict": "incomplete", "hardGreen": false, "deterministicGreen": true, "deterministicChecks": 14, "criteriaAttempted": 4, "runtimeErrors": 0, "receiptKey": "v7:sfull:q3:a0:finding-14wh26j", "highIssues": 0 }, "efficiency": { "fullPasses": 1, "staticCriteria": 0, "staticDeterministic": 0, "staticBatchCalls": 0, "staticBatchRetries": 0, "workflowCalls": 1, "workflowCriteria": 0, "deferred": 1, "receiptHits": 22 }, "stages": { "workflowPlan": { "calls": 1, "tokens": 1318, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 89001 }, "criterionTurn": { "calls": 18, "tokens": 35295, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 267111 }, "finalJudge": { "calls": 1, "tokens": 9304, "costUsd": 0, "wallMs": 31569 } }, "purposes": { "standard": 1 }, "criteria": [ { "id": "criterion-1786161619558-yrr64", "text": "index.html loads the app via at least 4 separate JS modules (e.g. state/persistence, recipe logic, shopping list, rendering, event wiring) instead of one app.js, using