{
"at": "2026-08-04T09:59:54.013Z",
"account": {
"id": "account-local-qwen",
"label": "Local AI",
"type": "local",
"model": "qwen3.6-35b-a3b-32k-fast"
},
"runsPerTask": 3,
"suite": "hard",
"taskFilter": null,
"durationMs": 24918276,
"summary": {
"tasks": 5,
"taskRunsPassed": 8,
"taskRunsTotal": 15,
"cleanCompletions": 0,
"outcomes": {
"complete": 0,
"complete_unverified": 0,
"needs_user": 0,
"timeout": 15,
"other": 0,
"falseCompletions": 0
},
"checksPassed": 107,
"checksTotal": 123,
"totalCostUsd": 0,
"totalProviderCalls": 1041,
"totalTokens": 3950459,
"providerUsageByAgent": {
"mira": {
"calls": 182,
"inTokens": 619174,
"outTokens": 70087,
"costUsd": 0
},
"forge": {
"calls": 220,
"inTokens": 1380347,
"outTokens": 655736,
"costUsd": 0
},
"verity": {
"calls": 625,
"inTokens": 1054379,
"outTokens": 133121,
"costUsd": 0
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 13,
"inTokens": 17306,
"outTokens": 16071,
"costUsd": 0
},
"sentinel": {
"calls": 1,
"inTokens": 4185,
"outTokens": 53,
"costUsd": 0
}
},
"totalSteps": 162
},
"results": [
{
"taskId": "hard-build-invoice-studio",
"kind": "build",
"run": 1,
"passed": false,
"checks": [
{
"name": "index.html exists",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors, empty invoice shows $0.00",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "math: two items → correct subtotal",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "interaction: 10% discount then 20% tax → $248.40 (order matters)",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "remove recomputes: deleting a row updates subtotal and total",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: empty description rejected, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: hostile qty/price rejected, totals never NaN",
"ok": false,
"error": "NaN/Infinity/undefined leaked into the page"
},
{
"name": "discount out of range: error shown, treated as 0",
"ok": false,
"error": "#inv-error stayed empty for a 250% discount"
},
{
"name": "persistence: items and totals survive a reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 3,
"behavioralUnproven": 3,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 11,
"wallMs": 1500794,
"usage": {
"tokens": 210506,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 75,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 42676,
"outTokens": 5335,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 11
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 50745,
"outTokens": 25527,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 11
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 71935,
"outTokens": 11585,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 52
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 1192,
"outTokens": 1511,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 1
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 3,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 6,
"total": 9
},
"selfReviews": 1,
"criteriaProven": 3,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 2,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 1,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 4,
"fixHistory": 4,
"broadRegen": 1,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": false,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 11,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 23131,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16638
},
"forge": {
"calls": 12,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 41982,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 31101
},
"verity": {
"calls": 52,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 6347,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 6170
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 1,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 4827,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 4827
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785813849953,
"workspaceVersion": 5,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 10,
"criteriaAttempted": 6,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 3
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 3,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 10,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 6,
"staticBatchRetries": 1
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-c9rty",
"text": "The page contains input#item-desc, input#item-qty, input#item-price, button#add-item, div#item-list, span#subtotal, input#discount-pct, input#tax-pct, span#total, and div#inv-error.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-jl90s",
"text": "Adding an item with description 'Widget', qty 2, price 10.00 creates a row in #item-list showing the details and a line total of $20.00.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 24,
"successfulActions": 24,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": true,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-tsxwy",
"text": "Clicking a .remove-item button removes that specific row from #item-list and updates all totals.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 20,
"successfulActions": 18,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-9t1t3",
"text": "#subtotal displays the sum of (qty * price) for all items, formatted as currency (e.g., $20.00).",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-awckv",
"text": "#total displays (subtotal - discount) + tax, formatted as currency with two decimals (e.g., $22.00).",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-mwvwh",
"text": "Validation: Empty description on add is rejected (no item added, error shown in #inv-error).",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 7,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-0fgm6",
"text": "Validation: Non-positive number for qty or price on add is rejected (no item added, error shown in #inv-error).",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 20,
"successfulActions": 19,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": true,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785812695512-h9q25",
"text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly id=\"item-desc\", id=\"item-qty\", id=\"item-price\", id=\"add-item\", id=\"item-list\", class=\"remove-item\", id=\"subtotal\", id=\"discount-pct\", id=\"tax-pct\", id=\"total\", id=\"inv-error\", \"item-desc\".",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 10,
"successfulActions": 10,
"modelCalls": 8,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 7
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-build-invoice-studio",
"kind": "build",
"run": 2,
"passed": false,
"checks": [
{
"name": "index.html exists",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors, empty invoice shows $0.00",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "math: two items → correct subtotal",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "interaction: 10% discount then 20% tax → $248.40 (order matters)",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "remove recomputes: deleting a row updates subtotal and total",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: empty description rejected, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: hostile qty/price rejected, totals never NaN",
"ok": false,
"error": "NaN/Infinity/undefined leaked into the page"
},
{
"name": "discount out of range: error shown, treated as 0",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "persistence: items and totals survive a reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 0,
"behavioralUnproven": 1,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 19,
"wallMs": 1559074,
"usage": {
"tokens": 301521,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 77,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 77615,
"outTokens": 6678,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 23
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 69897,
"outTokens": 25333,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 12
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 97754,
"outTokens": 14391,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 39
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 2381,
"outTokens": 3234,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 2
},
"sentinel": {
"inTokens": 4185,
"outTokens": 53,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 1
}
}
},
"verdict": "incomplete",
"criteria": {
"met": 7,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 6,
"total": 7
},
"selfReviews": 1,
"criteriaProven": 7,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 0,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 1,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 1,
"fixHistory": 1,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": false,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 23,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 18155,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16209
},
"forge": {
"calls": 12,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 38442,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 38442
},
"verity": {
"calls": 40,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 25111,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 23681
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 2,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 5141,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 5141
},
"sentinel": {
"calls": 1,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 16367,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16367
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785815743785,
"workspaceVersion": 4,
"verdict": "incomplete",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": true,
"deterministicChecks": 11,
"criteriaAttempted": 7,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 0
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 3,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 6,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 3,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-1d7o0",
"text": "The page contains input fields with id='item-desc', id='item-qty', id='item-price', a button with id='add-item', and a container with id='item-list'.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-vosxf",
"text": "Clicking 'Add' with valid description, positive quantity, and positive price adds a row to #item-list showing the line total.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-d19oa",
"text": "Each item row contains a button with class='remove-item' that removes the row and recomputes totals.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 9,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "model-no-response",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-8r687",
"text": "An element with id='subtotal' displays the sum of all line totals.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-frggh",
"text": "Inputs with id='discount-pct' and id='tax-pct' allow setting percentages.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-ljy3s",
"text": "An element with id='total' displays the final total: (subtotal - discount) + tax, formatted as $X.XX.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 4,
"successfulActions": 4,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-y6phk",
"text": "Totals recompute automatically on any change to inputs or item list.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 14,
"successfulActions": 10,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785814207307-910s4",
"text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly id=\"item-desc\", id=\"item-qty\", id=\"item-price\", id=\"add-item\", id=\"item-list\", class=\"remove-item\", id=\"subtotal\", id=\"discount-pct\", id=\"tax-pct\", id=\"total\", id=\"inv-error\", \"item-desc\"; negative requirements hold literally (NEVER display NaN).",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 10,
"successfulActions": 8,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [
"Invoice Preview & Print Mode (attempted — did not land)"
],
"backlogRemaining": 6
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-build-invoice-studio",
"kind": "build",
"run": 3,
"passed": false,
"checks": [
{
"name": "index.html exists",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors, empty invoice shows $0.00",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "math: two items → correct subtotal",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "interaction: 10% discount then 20% tax → $248.40 (order matters)",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "remove recomputes: deleting a row updates subtotal and total",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: empty description rejected, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: hostile qty/price rejected, totals never NaN",
"ok": false,
"error": "NaN/Infinity/undefined leaked into the page"
},
{
"name": "discount out of range: error shown, treated as 0",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "persistence: items and totals survive a reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 0,
"behavioralUnproven": 1,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 11,
"wallMs": 1500651,
"usage": {
"tokens": 218636,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 68,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 40478,
"outTokens": 5057,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 13
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 38882,
"outTokens": 41267,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 9
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 78810,
"outTokens": 11507,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 45
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 1155,
"outTokens": 1480,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 1
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 7,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 7,
"total": 7
},
"selfReviews": 1,
"criteriaProven": 7,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 0,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 0,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 0,
"fixHistory": 0,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": false,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 13,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 17104,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 17070
},
"forge": {
"calls": 9,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 32008,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 32008
},
"verity": {
"calls": 46,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 20129,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 6191
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 1,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 4765,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 4765
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785817252404,
"workspaceVersion": 3,
"verdict": "pass",
"hardGreen": true,
"deterministicGreen": true,
"deterministicChecks": 4,
"criteriaAttempted": 0,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 0
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 3,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 6,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 3,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-ompke",
"text": "The page contains input elements with id='item-desc', id='item-qty', id='item-price', an add button with id='add-item', and a list container with id='item-list'.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-q3q50",
"text": "Each item row in #item-list displays its description, quantity, unit price, and line total (qty * price).",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 8,
"successfulActions": 8,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-zun0y",
"text": "Each item row has a Remove button with class='remove-item' that deletes the row and recomputes totals.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 20,
"successfulActions": 20,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-lb4i3",
"text": "An element with id='subtotal' shows the sum of all line totals.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-9tk28",
"text": "An input with id='discount-pct' allows entering a discount percentage.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-nywx1",
"text": "An input with id='tax-pct' allows entering a tax percentage.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-eum3r",
"text": "An element with id='total' shows the final total formatted as currency (e.g., $1,234.56), calculated as (subtotal - discount) + tax.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 14,
"successfulActions": 10,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785815771095-ck038",
"text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly id=\"item-desc\", id=\"item-qty\", id=\"item-price\", id=\"add-item\", id=\"item-list\", class=\"remove-item\", id=\"subtotal\", id=\"discount-pct\", id=\"tax-pct\", id=\"total\", id=\"inv-error\", \"item-desc\"; negative requirements hold literally (NEVER display NaN).",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 7
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-modify-crm-features",
"kind": "modify",
"run": 1,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "regression: add updates list and count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "regression: search stays case-insensitive",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "regression: empty name rejected with an error, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "regression: delete works and detail panel still opens",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "tags: saved on add and shown as .tag chips in the detail panel",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "tag filter: options populate and filtering works",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "export: #export-output holds parseable JSON containing the contacts",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "import: merges new contacts, skips duplicate emails",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "undo: restores the most recently deleted contact",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 2,
"behavioralUnproven": 6,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 5,
"wallMs": 1500902,
"usage": {
"tokens": 196428,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 44,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 17550,
"outTokens": 1866,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 5
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 83269,
"outTokens": 45044,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 12
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 43213,
"outTokens": 5486,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 27
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 2,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 2,
"total": 7
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 2,
"digest": false,
"shortcuts": 1,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 20,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 1,
"fixHistory": 1,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 5,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 20243,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 15196
},
"forge": {
"calls": 12,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 46862,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 30211
},
"verity": {
"calls": 27,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 6950,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 6934
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785817821597,
"workspaceVersion": 7,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 12,
"criteriaAttempted": 4,
"runtimeErrors": 1,
"highIssues": 6
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 1,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-ubuzh",
"text": "The add form contains an input with id=\"contact-tags\" that accepts comma-separated tags.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 1,
"successfulActions": 1,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "model-returned-unknown",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-4jptj",
"text": "When a contact is added with tags, those tags are saved and displayed in the detail panel as elements with class=\"tag\".",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 5,
"successfulActions": 5,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-44351",
"text": "A select element with id=\"tag-filter\" exists above the contact list, with an option \"All tags\" (value=\"\") and one option per distinct tag in use.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-e05me",
"text": "Selecting a specific tag in #tag-filter filters the contact list to show only contacts possessing that tag; selecting \"All tags\" shows all contacts.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 7,
"successfulActions": 7,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-dxtny",
"text": "A button with id=\"export\" exists and, when clicked, writes the full contact list as a JSON string into a textarea with id=\"export-output\".",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 3,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-0otja",
"text": "A textarea with id=\"import-input\" and a button with id=\"import-btn\" exist; clicking import-btn parses the textarea's JSON array content and merges contacts into the store, skipping any whose email already exists (case-insensitive).",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 4,
"successfulActions": 4,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-5ecf4",
"text": "After a contact is deleted, a button with id=\"undo\" appears; clicking it restores the most recently deleted contact.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 7,
"successfulActions": 7,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785817280201-vtqm3",
"text": "Adding a contact still validates required fields and rejects duplicates based on case-insensitive email matching.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 5,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 0,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 0
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-modify-crm-features",
"kind": "modify",
"run": 2,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "regression: add updates list and count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "regression: search stays case-insensitive",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "regression: empty name rejected with an error, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "regression: delete works and detail panel still opens",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "tags: saved on add and shown as .tag chips in the detail panel",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "tag filter: options populate and filtering works",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "export: #export-output holds parseable JSON containing the contacts",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "import: merges new contacts, skips duplicate emails",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "undo: restores the most recently deleted contact",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 1,
"behavioralUnproven": 4,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 12,
"wallMs": 1500663,
"usage": {
"tokens": 291634,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 76,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 48091,
"outTokens": 4987,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 13
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 69532,
"outTokens": 7317,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 43
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 131109,
"outTokens": 28260,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 19
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 1127,
"outTokens": 1211,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 1
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 4,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 5,
"total": 7
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 4,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 2,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 37,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 2,
"fixHistory": 2,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 13,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 22668,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16990
},
"verity": {
"calls": 43,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 7018,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 6610
},
"forge": {
"calls": 19,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 41715,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 33098
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 1,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 4832,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 4832
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785820005683,
"workspaceVersion": 12,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 13,
"criteriaAttempted": 5,
"runtimeErrors": 1,
"highIssues": 4
},
"efficiency": {
"fullPasses": 5,
"scopedPasses": 0,
"deferred": 2,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-ivvt4",
"text": "The add form contains a comma-separated tags input with id=\"contact-tags\".",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 8,
"successfulActions": 8,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-nl6t2",
"text": "Tags entered in #contact-tags are saved with the contact and displayed in the detail panel as elements with class=\"tag\".",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 17,
"successfulActions": 17,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-0jmgi",
"text": "A select element with id=\"tag-filter\" exists above the contact list with an option \"All tags\" (value \"\") and options for every distinct tag in use.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-zqed1",
"text": "Selecting a tag in #tag-filter filters the contact list to show only contacts having that tag.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 8,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-y461n",
"text": "A button with id=\"export\" writes the full contact list as JSON into a textarea with id=\"export-output\".",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-4axf9",
"text": "A textarea with id=\"import-input\" and a button with id=\"import-btn\" parse a JSON array of contacts and merge them, skipping duplicates by case-insensitive email.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-jggoy",
"text": "After a contact is deleted, a button with id=\"undo\" appears and restores the most recently deleted contact.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 9,
"successfulActions": 9,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785818789171-9jr9u",
"text": "Existing features still work: adding with validation/duplicate-email rejection, live search, count display, detail panel viewing, deleting, and persistence across reload.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 18,
"successfulActions": 18,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "missing-required-actions",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 6
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-modify-crm-features",
"kind": "modify",
"run": 3,
"passed": false,
"checks": [
{
"name": "regression: add updates list and count",
"ok": false,
"error": "#contact-count shows \"0 contacts\""
},
{
"name": "regression: search stays case-insensitive",
"ok": false,
"error": "search \"ada\" shows: "
},
{
"name": "regression: empty name rejected with an error, nothing added",
"ok": false,
"error": "#form-error stayed empty"
},
{
"name": "regression: delete works and detail panel still opens",
"ok": false,
"error": "page.click: Timeout 5000ms exceeded.\nCall log:\n\u001b[2m - waiting for locator('#contact-list li:first-child')\u001b[22m\n"
},
{
"name": "tags: saved on add and shown as .tag chips in the detail panel",
"ok": false,
"error": "page.click: Timeout 5000ms exceeded.\nCall log:\n\u001b[2m - waiting for locator('#contact-list li:first-child')\u001b[22m\n"
},
{
"name": "tag filter: options populate and filtering works",
"ok": false,
"error": "page.selectOption: Timeout 5000ms exceeded.\nCall log:\n\u001b[2m - waiting for locator('#tag-filter')\u001b[22m\n\u001b[2m - locator resolved to \u001b[22m\n\u001b[2m - attempting select option action\u001b[22m\n\u001b[2m 2 × waiting for element to be visible and enabled\u001b[22m\n\u001b[2m - did not "
},
{
"name": "export: #export-output holds parseable JSON containing the contacts",
"ok": false,
"error": "exported JSON is missing the contact"
},
{
"name": "import: merges new contacts, skips duplicate emails",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "undo: restores the most recently deleted contact",
"ok": false,
"error": "page.click: Timeout 5000ms exceeded.\nCall log:\n\u001b[2m - waiting for locator('#contact-list li:first-child .delete')\u001b[22m\n"
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 0,
"behavioralUnproven": 5,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 14,
"wallMs": 1566673,
"usage": {
"tokens": 317488,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 96,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 54597,
"outTokens": 5724,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 16
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 117654,
"outTokens": 33426,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 20
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 89442,
"outTokens": 11693,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 58
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 2959,
"outTokens": 1993,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 2
}
}
},
"verdict": "fail",
"criteria": {
"met": 3,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 4,
"total": 5
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 3,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 0,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 41,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 2,
"fixHistory": 2,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 16,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 21886,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16950
},
"forge": {
"calls": 20,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 36557,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 382
},
"verity": {
"calls": 59,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 6910,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 4322
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 2,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 7613,
"budgetChars": 88474,
"lastChars": 7613
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785821849027,
"workspaceVersion": 8,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 11,
"criteriaAttempted": 3,
"runtimeErrors": 1,
"highIssues": 2
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 4,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-js9ex",
"text": "The add form contains an input with id=\"contact-tags\" for entering comma-separated tags.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": true,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-3hx7r",
"text": "When a contact is added, its tags are saved and displayed in the detail panel as elements with class=\"tag\".",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 14,
"successfulActions": 14,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-m5a60",
"text": "A select element with id=\"tag-filter\" exists above the contact list with an option \"All tags\" (value \"\").",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-6rqpm",
"text": "The tag-filter populates options for every distinct tag currently in use by any contact.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 15,
"successfulActions": 15,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "missing-required-actions",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-3uvdc",
"text": "Selecting a specific tag in tag-filter filters the contact list to show only contacts having that tag; selecting \"All tags\" shows all contacts.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 17,
"successfulActions": 17,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "model-no-response",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-dujpz",
"text": "A button with id=\"export\" exists and, when clicked, writes the full contact list as a JSON string into a textarea with id=\"export-output\".",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 10,
"successfulActions": 10,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-uglrg",
"text": "A textarea with id=\"import-input\" and a button with id=\"import-btn\" exist; clicking import-btn parses the textarea's JSON content and merges contacts into the store, skipping those with duplicate emails (case-insensitive).",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 7,
"successfulActions": 7,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785820302074-4ml7f",
"text": "After a contact is deleted, a button with id=\"undo\" appears; clicking it restores the most recently deleted contact.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 7,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 7,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "model-returned-unknown",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 5
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-fix-crm-tangle",
"kind": "fix",
"run": 1,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "regression: add, count and detail still work",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 1: search is case-insensitive again",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 2: deleting under an active search removes the RIGHT contact",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 3: contacts survive a page reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 2,
"behavioralUnproven": 3,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 8,
"wallMs": 1590235,
"usage": {
"tokens": 217823,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 48,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 25657,
"outTokens": 2151,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 8
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 29223,
"outTokens": 4121,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 23
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 107430,
"outTokens": 49241,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 17
}
}
},
"verdict": "fail",
"criteria": {
"met": 0,
"total": 3
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 5,
"total": 6
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 0,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 2,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 28,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 3,
"fixHistory": 3,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 8,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 17815,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 17344
},
"verity": {
"calls": 23,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 5463,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 5297
},
"forge": {
"calls": 16,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 36917,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 28319
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785822950026,
"workspaceVersion": 6,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 10,
"criteriaAttempted": 2,
"runtimeErrors": 1,
"highIssues": 6
},
"efficiency": {
"fullPasses": 4,
"scopedPasses": 0,
"deferred": 1,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785821889716-z99l8",
"text": "Search finds contacts regardless of capitalization (case-insensitive search).",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 13,
"modelCalls": 8,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785821889716-ynmvi",
"text": "When a search is active, clicking Delete removes only the specific contact clicked, not a different one.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 7,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785821889716-5tp3j",
"text": "Contacts persist after refreshing the page (using localStorage or similar persistence mechanism).",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 16,
"successfulActions": 16,
"modelCalls": 8,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 0,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 0
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-fix-crm-tangle",
"kind": "fix",
"run": 2,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "regression: add, count and detail still work",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 1: search is case-insensitive again",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 2: deleting under an active search removes the RIGHT contact",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 3: contacts survive a page reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 3,
"behavioralUnproven": 3,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 13,
"wallMs": 1590376,
"usage": {
"tokens": 275963,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 82,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 54235,
"outTokens": 4296,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 16
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 60529,
"outTokens": 8395,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 48
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 112185,
"outTokens": 34363,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 17
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 792,
"outTokens": 1168,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 1
}
}
},
"verdict": "fail",
"criteria": {
"met": 1,
"total": 4
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 4,
"total": 5
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 1,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 0,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 37,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 3,
"fixHistory": 3,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 16,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 20035,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 19115
},
"verity": {
"calls": 48,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 5772,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 5272
},
"forge": {
"calls": 18,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 38226,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 38226
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 1,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 3348,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 3348
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785824566610,
"workspaceVersion": 6,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 11,
"criteriaAttempted": 3,
"runtimeErrors": 1,
"highIssues": 8
},
"efficiency": {
"fullPasses": 7,
"scopedPasses": 0,
"deferred": 3,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785823486965-5t2i9",
"text": "Search is case-insensitive: typing 'alice' finds 'Alice'.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 7,
"actionAttempts": 17,
"successfulActions": 16,
"modelCalls": 14,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785823486965-lf38u",
"text": "Delete button removes the correct contact displayed in the search results.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 7,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 13,
"modelCalls": 13,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785823486965-qxk3f",
"text": "Contacts persist after page refresh (stored in localStorage or similar).",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 7,
"actionAttempts": 25,
"successfulActions": 25,
"modelCalls": 14,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785823486965-fc483",
"text": "The app renders a list of contacts and allows adding new ones.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 20,
"successfulActions": 16,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 6
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "hard-fix-crm-tangle",
"kind": "fix",
"run": 3,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "regression: add, count and detail still work",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 1: search is case-insensitive again",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 2: deleting under an active search removes the RIGHT contact",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "bug 3: contacts survive a page reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 2,
"behavioralUnproven": 4,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 5,
"wallMs": 1500811,
"usage": {
"tokens": 170346,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 40,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 16140,
"outTokens": 1634,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 5
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 29671,
"outTokens": 3113,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 25
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 61864,
"outTokens": 57924,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 10
}
}
},
"verdict": "fail",
"criteria": {
"met": 1,
"total": 5
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 3,
"total": 9
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 1,
"digest": false,
"shortcuts": 1,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 13,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 2,
"fixHistory": 2,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 5,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 17068,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 17068
},
"verity": {
"calls": 25,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 5508,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 5096
},
"forge": {
"calls": 10,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 33585,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 33585
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785826114509,
"workspaceVersion": 5,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 11,
"criteriaAttempted": 3,
"runtimeErrors": 1,
"highIssues": 6
},
"efficiency": {
"fullPasses": 3,
"scopedPasses": 0,
"deferred": 1,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785825085739-qnldi",
"text": "Bug 1 Fix: Searching for a contact with different capitalization (e.g., 'alice' vs 'Alice') successfully finds and displays the contact.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 8,
"successfulActions": 8,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785825085739-lblqt",
"text": "Bug 2 Fix: When a search is active, clicking the Delete button on a specific contact removes ONLY that contact and not any other.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 3,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785825085739-ywaii",
"text": "Bug 3 Fix: After refreshing the page, all previously added contacts are still present (data persistence works).",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785825085739-j8tia",
"text": "Preservation: The app's UI structure and element IDs remain unchanged.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785825085739-e4056",
"text": "Preservation: All existing features (Add, Delete, Search, Display) continue to function as intended.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 0,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 0
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "vhard-refactor-recipe-monolith",
"kind": "refactor",
"run": 1,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "structure: at least 4 JS files and no giant file left",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: add recipe updates list and stats; bad time rejected",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: ingredients + scaling math (4 → 10 servings, 2.5×)",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: shopping list merges duplicates instead of double-listing",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: favorites toggle + stats count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: search + category filter + time sort still compose",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: notes save and persist; recipes survive reload",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "new feature: Duplicate creates a full copy named \"(copy)\"",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "new feature: #clear-shopping empties the shopping list",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 5,
"behavioralUnproven": 5,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 6,
"wallMs": 1800186,
"usage": {
"tokens": 252403,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 58,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 25832,
"outTokens": 3185,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 8
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 77700,
"outTokens": 67772,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 10
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 69538,
"outTokens": 8376,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 40
}
}
},
"verdict": "fail",
"criteria": {
"met": 1,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 9,
"total": 12
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 1,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 0,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 6,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 2,
"fixHistory": 2,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 8,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 19392,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 19392
},
"forge": {
"calls": 10,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 48199,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 48199
},
"verity": {
"calls": 40,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 7525,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 7525
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785828301521,
"workspaceVersion": 12,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 15,
"criteriaAttempted": 6,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 5
},
"efficiency": {
"fullPasses": 3,
"scopedPasses": 0,
"deferred": 2,
"staticCriteria": 6,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 4,
"staticBatchRetries": 1
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-yidem",
"text": "The application is split into at least four separate JavaScript modules loaded from index.html (e.g., state.js, recipeLogic.js, shoppingList.js, rendering.js, eventHandler.js).",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 3,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-i2zq5",
"text": "Every recipe row has a Duplicate button with class=\"dup-recipe\" that creates a full copy of the recipe (including ingredients) named \" (copy)\".",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-kvdvp",
"text": "A button with id=\"clear-shopping\" exists under the shopping list and empties it when clicked.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 9,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-slyxb",
"text": "Adding recipes works with validation (name, category, etc.) and persists across reloads.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 7,
"successfulActions": 7,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "missing-required-actions",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-q51qj",
"text": "Selecting a recipe displays its details, including ingredients and instructions.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 9,
"successfulActions": 9,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-u8oah",
"text": "Ingredients can be added to a selected recipe.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-mi6s8",
"text": "Serving-size scaling correctly adjusts ingredient quantities.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785826594875-abikp",
"text": "The shopping list merges duplicate ingredients from multiple recipes and persists across reloads.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 8,
"successfulActions": 8,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "missing-required-actions",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 0,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 0
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "vhard-refactor-recipe-monolith",
"kind": "refactor",
"run": 2,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "structure: at least 4 JS files and no giant file left",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: add recipe updates list and stats; bad time rejected",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: ingredients + scaling math (4 → 10 servings, 2.5×)",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: shopping list merges duplicates instead of double-listing",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: favorites toggle + stats count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: search + category filter + time sort still compose",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: notes save and persist; recipes survive reload",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "new feature: Duplicate creates a full copy named \"(copy)\"",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "new feature: #clear-shopping empties the shopping list",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 0,
"behavioralUnproven": 5,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 14,
"wallMs": 1844406,
"usage": {
"tokens": 319785,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 63,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 49484,
"outTokens": 5771,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 15
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 159439,
"outTokens": 61581,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 25
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 1563,
"outTokens": 831,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 1
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 37266,
"outTokens": 3850,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 22
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 3,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 8,
"total": 10
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 3,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 0,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 40,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 3,
"fixHistory": 3,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 15,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 19621,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16143
},
"forge": {
"calls": 25,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 44620,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 38818
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 1,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 6635,
"budgetChars": 88474,
"lastChars": 6635
},
"verity": {
"calls": 22,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 7350,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 7350
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785829587704,
"workspaceVersion": 10,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 18,
"criteriaAttempted": 8,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 5
},
"efficiency": {
"fullPasses": 4,
"scopedPasses": 0,
"deferred": 3,
"staticCriteria": 6,
"staticDeterministic": 2,
"staticBatchCalls": 2,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-ii5ux",
"text": "The application code is split into at least four separate JavaScript modules (e.g., state, logic, shopping, rendering) loaded from index.html.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 3,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-f3xio",
"text": "Every recipe row has a Duplicate button with class='dup-recipe' that creates a copy named ' (copy)' including all ingredients.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 2,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-x4m12",
"text": "There is a button with id='clear-shopping' under the shopping list that empties it.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-d8d6w",
"text": "Adding recipes with validation works as before.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 5,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-mgay5",
"text": "Selecting a recipe displays its details correctly.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-69q0x",
"text": "Adding ingredients to a selected recipe works as before.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 6,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-hphre",
"text": "Serving-size scaling updates ingredient quantities correctly.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 3,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785828408891-05t9k",
"text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly class=\"dup-recipe\", id=\"clear-shopping\", \"dup-recipe\", \" (copy)\", \"clear-shopping\".",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 2,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 0,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 0
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "vhard-refactor-recipe-monolith",
"kind": "refactor",
"run": 3,
"passed": true,
"checks": [
{
"name": "structure: at least 4 JS files and no giant file left",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: add recipe updates list and stats; bad time rejected",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: ingredients + scaling math (4 → 10 servings, 2.5×)",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: shopping list merges duplicates instead of double-listing",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: favorites toggle + stats count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: search + category filter + time sort still compose",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "behavior: notes save and persist; recipes survive reload",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "new feature: Duplicate creates a full copy named \"(copy)\"",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "new feature: #clear-shopping empties the shopping list",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 5,
"behavioralUnproven": 4,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 12,
"wallMs": 1800487,
"usage": {
"tokens": 366003,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 97,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 48650,
"outTokens": 5015,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 15
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 153185,
"outTokens": 35548,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 18
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 110191,
"outTokens": 13414,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 64
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 2,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 8,
"total": 10
},
"selfReviews": 0,
"criteriaProven": 2,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 1,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 36,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 2,
"fixHistory": 2,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": true,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 15,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 19926,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16402
},
"forge": {
"calls": 19,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 55044,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 41308
},
"verity": {
"calls": 64,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 7514,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 7277
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785831736863,
"workspaceVersion": 13,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 15,
"criteriaAttempted": 6,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 5
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 2,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 10,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 5,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-xphsg",
"text": "The application code is split into at least four separate JavaScript modules loaded from index.html.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 5,
"successfulActions": 5,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-t60tq",
"text": "Every recipe row contains a Duplicate button with class=\"dup-recipe\" that creates a copy of the recipe named \" (copy)\" including all ingredients.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-gqc9x",
"text": "A button with id=\"clear-shopping\" exists under the shopping list and empties it when clicked.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 11,
"successfulActions": 11,
"modelCalls": 8,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-fwxnm",
"text": "Adding recipes with validation works as before (e.g., required fields, valid input).",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 10,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "missing-required-actions",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-4k14s",
"text": "Selecting a recipe displays its details correctly.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 13,
"modelCalls": 10,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-svkho",
"text": "Adding ingredients to a selected recipe works correctly.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 11,
"successfulActions": 11,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-cd1bv",
"text": "Serving-size scaling updates ingredient quantities proportionally.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 15,
"successfulActions": 15,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785830312676-6z4z8",
"text": "The shopping list merges duplicate ingredients and sums quantities.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 5,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 0,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 0
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "vhard-build-flashcards-pro",
"kind": "build",
"run": 1,
"passed": false,
"checks": [
{
"name": "index.html exists",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "decks and cards: add, select, count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: empty front rejected, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "review flow: front shown, back hidden until reveal",
"ok": false,
"error": "back visible before reveal"
},
{
"name": "scheduling: easy → due in (new box) sessions; hard → due next session",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "stats line stays in the exact \"N cards · M due\" shape",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "export: parseable JSON with decks and cards",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "persistence: deck, cards, boxes and session counter survive reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 4,
"behavioralUnproven": 5,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 10,
"wallMs": 1800039,
"usage": {
"tokens": 300152,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 93,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 27983,
"outTokens": 3207,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 8
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 64354,
"outTokens": 45341,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 11
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 138417,
"outTokens": 15673,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 72
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 2731,
"outTokens": 2446,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 2
}
}
},
"verdict": "fail",
"criteria": {
"met": 3,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 7,
"total": 8
},
"selfReviews": 1,
"criteriaProven": 3,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 3,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 0,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 3,
"fixHistory": 3,
"broadRegen": 1,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": false,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 9,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 20421,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 20421
},
"forge": {
"calls": 10,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 35796,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 9387
},
"verity": {
"calls": 72,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 30226,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 6953
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 2,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 5843,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 5843
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785833857003,
"workspaceVersion": 4,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 11,
"criteriaAttempted": 7,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 4
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 1,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-ainu6",
"text": "The page contains input#deck-name, button#add-deck, and list container#deck-list; clicking add-deck adds a deck to the list.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 7,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": true,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-wqzd2",
"text": "Clicking a deck in #deck-list selects it and displays its name in element#current-deck.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 10,
"successfulActions": 8,
"modelCalls": 7,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-mvd6j",
"text": "With a deck selected, inputs#card-front and#card-back plus button#add-card allow adding cards; an empty front is rejected with a message in#card-error and adds no card.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 6,
"actionAttempts": 16,
"successfulActions": 16,
"modelCalls": 12,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-n8bjn",
"text": "Element#card-count shows the number of cards in the currently selected deck in the format 'N cards'.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 21,
"successfulActions": 17,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-wyk77",
"text": "Element#session-num displays the current session number for the selected deck, starting at 1.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 7,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": true,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-5hwv6",
"text": "Element#due-count shows the number of due cards in the selected deck (due-session <= current session).",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 5,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "model-returned-unknown",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-4k0x5",
"text": "Button#start-review begins a review session; card fronts appear in#review-front and backs are hidden until#reveal is clicked, showing them in#review-back.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 6,
"actionAttempts": 18,
"successfulActions": 15,
"modelCalls": 9,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785832083527-dvfrc",
"text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly id=\"deck-name\", id=\"add-deck\", id=\"deck-list\", id=\"current-deck\", id=\"card-front\", id=\"card-back\", id=\"add-card\", id=\"card-count\", id=\"card-error\", id=\"session-num\", id=\"due-count\", id=\"start-review\".",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 7,
"successfulActions": 7,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": true,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 6
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "vhard-build-flashcards-pro",
"kind": "build",
"run": 2,
"passed": false,
"checks": [
{
"name": "index.html exists",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "decks and cards: add, select, count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: empty front rejected, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "review flow: front shown, back hidden until reveal",
"ok": false,
"error": "back visible before reveal"
},
{
"name": "scheduling: easy → due in (new box) sessions; hard → due next session",
"ok": false,
"error": "session counter did not advance to 2"
},
{
"name": "stats line stays in the exact \"N cards · M due\" shape",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "export: parseable JSON with decks and cards",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "persistence: deck, cards, boxes and session counter survive reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 0,
"behavioralUnproven": 2,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 13,
"wallMs": 1800322,
"usage": {
"tokens": 281970,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 66,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 50005,
"outTokens": 5544,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 14
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 88667,
"outTokens": 48870,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 17
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 74172,
"outTokens": 9109,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 33
},
"advisor": {
"inTokens": 3406,
"outTokens": 2197,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 2
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 6,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 8,
"total": 8
},
"selfReviews": 1,
"criteriaProven": 6,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 1,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 3,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 0,
"fixHistory": 0,
"broadRegen": 0,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": false,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 14,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 18319,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16873
},
"forge": {
"calls": 18,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 34957,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 33859
},
"verity": {
"calls": 33,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 29843,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 22290
},
"advisor": {
"calls": 2,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 8741,
"budgetChars": 88474,
"lastChars": 8741
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785835588529,
"workspaceVersion": 2,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": true,
"deterministicChecks": 4,
"criteriaAttempted": 0,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 1
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 1,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 0,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 0,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-mgavf",
"text": "The page contains input#deck-name, button#add-deck, list#deck-list, and element#current-deck.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-c9rzi",
"text": "Adding a deck via #deck-name and #add-deck adds it to #deck-list and updates #current-deck with the new name.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 4,
"successfulActions": 4,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-ywrta",
"text": "Clicking a deck in #deck-list selects it and displays its name in #current-deck.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 4,
"successfulActions": 4,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-vafqf",
"text": "With a deck selected, inputs #card-front, #card-back and button #add-card are available to add cards.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 6,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 3,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-failed",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-jvuu4",
"text": "Element #card-count updates to show 'N cards' when cards are added or removed.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 14,
"successfulActions": 13,
"modelCalls": 7,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-5yte3",
"text": "Adding a card with an empty front shows an error message in #card-error and does not add the card.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 3,
"actionAttempts": 8,
"successfulActions": 8,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-y3s8y",
"text": "Element #session-num displays the current session number, starting at 1.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 2,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785833896776-5r5hl",
"text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly id=\"deck-name\", id=\"add-deck\", id=\"deck-list\", id=\"current-deck\", id=\"card-front\", id=\"card-back\", id=\"add-card\", id=\"card-count\", id=\"card-error\", id=\"session-num\", id=\"due-count\", id=\"start-review\".",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 2,
"actionAttempts": 3,
"successfulActions": 3,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 1,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 6
}
}
},
{
"taskId": "vhard-build-flashcards-pro",
"kind": "build",
"run": 3,
"passed": false,
"checks": [
{
"name": "index.html exists",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "loads without page errors",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "decks and cards: add, select, count",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "negative path: empty front rejected, nothing added",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "review flow: front shown, back hidden until reveal",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "scheduling: easy → due in (new box) sessions; hard → due next session",
"ok": false,
"error": "session counter did not advance to 2"
},
{
"name": "stats line stays in the exact \"N cards · M due\" shape",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "export: parseable JSON with decks and cards",
"ok": true
},
{
"name": "persistence: deck, cards, boxes and session counter survive reload",
"ok": true
}
],
"endState": "timeout",
"completedUnproven": false,
"failedCriteriaEnd": 2,
"behavioralUnproven": 3,
"timedOut": true,
"interventions": 0,
"providerRetries": 0,
"steps": 9,
"wallMs": 1890664,
"usage": {
"tokens": 229801,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 58,
"byAgent": {
"mira": {
"inTokens": 40181,
"outTokens": 9637,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 12
},
"forge": {
"inTokens": 63967,
"outTokens": 56239,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 12
},
"verity": {
"inTokens": 54686,
"outTokens": 5091,
"costUsd": 0,
"calls": 34
}
}
},
"verdict": "pass",
"criteria": {
"met": 3,
"total": 8
},
"loop": {
"planSteps": {
"done": 3,
"total": 8
},
"selfReviews": 1,
"criteriaProven": 3,
"digest": true,
"shortcuts": 0,
"completionShortcuts": 0,
"leanStubs": 1,
"skillsApplied": 0,
"skillsSaved": 0,
"fixAttempts": 3,
"fixHistory": 3,
"broadRegen": 1,
"holisticTried": false,
"providerRecoveries": 0,
"structureChecks": false,
"promptStats": {
"mira": {
"calls": 12,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 18853,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 16940
},
"forge": {
"calls": 13,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 40606,
"budgetChars": 58982,
"lastChars": 38604
},
"verity": {
"calls": 34,
"trims": 0,
"maxChars": 7303,
"budgetChars": 103219,
"lastChars": 7159
}
},
"providerQueue": {
"waits": 0,
"totalMs": 0,
"maxMs": 0
},
"verification": {
"lastRun": {
"at": 1785837081047,
"workspaceVersion": 4,
"verdict": "fail",
"hardGreen": false,
"deterministicGreen": false,
"deterministicChecks": 9,
"criteriaAttempted": 5,
"runtimeErrors": 0,
"highIssues": 2
},
"efficiency": {
"deferred": 4,
"fullPasses": null,
"staticCriteria": 8,
"staticDeterministic": 0,
"staticBatchCalls": 4,
"staticBatchRetries": 0
},
"criteria": [
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-6w7ur",
"text": "The page contains input #deck-name, button #add-deck, and list container #deck-list.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 0,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": true
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-puanf",
"text": "Adding a deck with id=\"deck-name\" and clicking #add-deck adds the deck to #deck-list and selects it, showing its name in #current-deck.",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 10,
"successfulActions": 10,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-ny9c8",
"text": "With a deck selected, inputs #card-front and #card-back plus button #add-card add a card; #card-count shows \"N cards\".",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 12,
"successfulActions": 12,
"modelCalls": 8,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-budget-exhausted",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-qkrxo",
"text": "An empty front is rejected with a message in #card-error and adds nothing.",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 11,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-failed",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-wozg1",
"text": "Every card has a box number (1-3) and due-session starting at 1; session counter in #session-num starts at 1.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-9odhu",
"text": "A card is DUE when its due-session <= current session; #due-count shows the count of due cards.",
"status": "failed",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 0,
"successfulActions": 0,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "failed",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-xi71d",
"text": "#start-review begins review: front shown in #review-front, back hidden until #reveal is clicked (shows in #review-back).",
"status": "open",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 13,
"successfulActions": 9,
"modelCalls": 4,
"lastResult": "unknown",
"unknownReason": "action-failed",
"replayAttempted": false,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
},
{
"id": "criterion-1785835708582-5wbm2",
"text": "Literal user contract: preserve exactly id=\"add-deck\", id=\"deck-list\", id=\"current-deck\", id=\"card-front\", id=\"card-back\", id=\"add-card\", id=\"card-count\", id=\"card-error\", id=\"session-num\", id=\"due-count\", id=\"start-review\", id=\"review-front\".",
"status": "met",
"attempts": 4,
"actionAttempts": 7,
"successfulActions": 7,
"modelCalls": 6,
"lastResult": "met",
"unknownReason": "",
"replayAttempted": true,
"replayFailed": false,
"deterministic": false
}
]
},
"improvements": {
"brainstormRounds": 0,
"shipped": [],
"backlogRemaining": 0
}
}
}
]
}